
Every year it’s the same—my students are hard on their own writing, but hardest on the sample essays we study in class. I’ll give them a 1-4-1 and I always hear the same remarks: “I feel like they’re just showing off,” or “this wasn’t even that good,” or “I could write better than this.” And yet…they don’t. Last week, I decided to try something during an open period I hadn’t planned yet. I decided it was time for an AP Lit Mock Reading.
For context: It’s important to know that this was an elaborate rehash on essays students had already written. The week before, they analyzed Richard Blanco’s “Shaving,” from the 2022 essay. This was a slightly dramatic way of handing back their scores on that essay, and giving them a needed reality check.
Why Sample Study Samples?
Studying sample essays is a crucial part of test preparation. So much of preparing for the AP Lit exam is learning to write the way that College Board rewards. Obviously we want students to be great writers and readers. However, with so many futures relying on earning top marks, it would be careless not to aim for high scoring essays. The biggest element of this is studying released essays and learning from them, both as teachers and as students.
Preparation
As students walked in, they were greeted with tables laid out with the following:
- A poetry prompt (Blanco’s “Shaving” from the 2022 reading)
- A printout of sample essays, released from College Board (see below for the file)
- An AP Lit poetry rubric
- A post it with their name on it
The post its told students where to sit, as I put them in small groups of 2-3. However, I invited them to create a persona to use when scoring, that of a high school English teacher or college professor. All crossed out their names and wrote up new names, such as “Professor Ander-Dingus,” “Professor Peppermint,” and “Elizabeth Erdrich.” (Many were professors at very prestigious universities, and I found that the more impressive the fake resume, the harder they were on scoring, but I’m getting ahead of myself.)
The Mock Reading
In a sudden act of whimsy, I grabbed my stapler and used it as a microphone, doing my best Steve Price impression. I welcomed students to the reading and thanked them for the sacrifice of time in order to serve the next generation of learners.
As AP Lit Mock Reading scorers, they were invited to re-read their poem and poetry prompt. It’s important to remember here that students wrote about this prompt the week earlier, so they were already familiar with it.
Furthermore, and they didn’t know this yet, I had just scored their essays on the poem.
Table groups began reading the poem, then reviewing the rubrics on the table. Once they were done, I invited each group to read over the sample essays and produce a score. I explained that these essays had already been scored and were being used as samples. Could they score them accurately with the rubric and match the sample scores?
As students began reading sample essays, they fell into their usual patterns. The first essay released from College Board, scored a 1-4-1 by sample scorers, is a bit more verbose and detailed than necessary. However, the line of reasoning is still strong and well-supported. Nonetheless, my students took no time in ripping it apart. Only one in my entire class felt it deserved a 1-4-1, while most gave it a 1-4-0, 1-3-0, and even a 1-2-0 because they found it annoying. This pattern continued, underscoring and undervaluing each essay in turn until they were finished.
A Twist on the Lesson
I put on my Steve Price microphone again, delivering a surprise to my students. To each, I handed out their own printed essay on Blanco’s “Shaving.” While I had scored these, the scores were safely locked away on AP Classroom and students hadn’t seen them yet. Students grabbed their essays, excited to learn of their own scores. Then, I spoke into my pretend microphone.

“Pass your essays to the right, please,” I said.
Suddenly, students began to panic. While I would never actually let a peer dictate their final scores, they began to realize that if they needed to answer to their own difficult grading expectations, they would suffer. And that, in fact, was precisely the point of the whole lesson.
Reward Students For What They Do Well
I didn’t need to do any of this in order to hand back scores. They were already graded and ready to hand back. However, I wanted students to be part of the attitude that all readers are instructed at the AP Reading, which is, “Reward students for what they do well.” What if, instead of focusing on what students did poorly in released on-demand essays, we focused on what they did well?
I watched my students read each other’s essays. I told them they should be ready to share what each writer did well, and perhaps what could be improved. Suddenly, their behavior was so much more civil. The praises abounded, as well as focused, constructive criticism. Many delivered the very criticism I had written in the feedback on AP Classroom. I decided they were ready to see their actual scores and feedback that I had given them.
For the first time all year, there was no grade grubbing, self-deprecating, or gloating. Everyone accepted their score as an honest reflection of a draft, which is what the AP Reading asks for. It’s quite impossible to write a perfect essay in 40 minutes, but isn’t it nice when we do a pretty good job?
Reflection
My hope with my AP Lit Mock Reading is to remind students of two things. 1) We don’t need perfection. The AP Reading asks you to do your best, and that is what we can try to do. 2) We probably aren’t capable of perfection. So don’t expect it in the sample essays when we study them in class.

This is a fun and thougtful way to get students truly thinking and speaking about the rubric. Thanks for sharing your work, Gina; I can’t wait to try this lesson!